Summer Allergies vs Colds: How to Tell the Difference (and When to See an ENT in Melbourne)
Summer in Melbourne brings long evenings, beach days, sport and time outdoors. It also brings…
Summer in Melbourne brings long evenings, beach days, sport and time outdoors. It also brings an uncomfortable mix of sneezing, runny noses and sore throats that can be hard to pin down. Many people in Melbourne and across Victoria are unsure whether they are dealing with hay fever, a summer cold or a throat problem that needs specialist attention.
Getting the diagnosis right is important. Misreading allergy symptoms as infection can lead to repeated courses of antibiotics that do not help. Assuming that every sore throat is “just a cold” can delay diagnosis of tonsil problems, sleep apnoea or chronic sinus disease. These issues can affect breathing, sleep, school, work and overall wellbeing.
Melbourne ENT, located in St Kilda East, is a specialist ear, nose and throat clinic caring for both adults and children. Patients are assessed by experienced ENT and Head & Neck Surgeon Dr Stephen Kleid and ENT Surgeon Dr Simon Braham. Together, they focus on careful diagnosis and evidence based management of nose, sinus and throat conditions, including problems that are often triggered or worsened during Melbourne’s summer months.
Summer allergies, often called hay fever or allergic rhinitis, occur when the immune system reacts to substances such as pollen, dust mites, pet dander or mould. In someone who is sensitised, the lining of the nose becomes inflamed after exposure to these triggers. This inflammation leads to sneezing, itching, a runny or blocked nose and sometimes throat and eye symptoms.
Although the name “hay fever” suggests infection, allergic rhinitis is not an infection and does not usually cause a true fever. It is an inflammatory response that can last for weeks or months while the person continues to encounter the allergen.
Melbourne and much of Victoria experience a very active spring and early summer grass pollen season. Hot, dry and windy days can blow large amounts of pollen across the city and suburbs, setting off sudden flares of symptoms in people who are sensitive. Outdoor activities such as sport, gardening or walking in parks around Melbourne can increase exposure.
Indoor allergens are also important. House dust mites in bedding and carpets, pet hair and dander, and mould in damp homes or workplaces can trigger symptoms all year. Many people have a combination of seasonal and indoor allergies that are particularly noticeable during warmer months when windows are open and time outdoors increases.
Allergic rhinitis tends to affect both sides of the nose. People notice bouts of sneezing, a runny nose with clear watery mucus, nasal blockage and itching inside the nose. Itchy, red, watery eyes are very common and can make reading, driving and computer work uncomfortable.
Some people describe an itchy or scratchy feeling in the throat or ears. Fatigue is also frequent, especially when allergies disturb sleep. Despite this, allergies do not usually cause high fever or the heavy “flu like” feeling that comes with many viral infections. Allergies are not contagious, so they do not spread from person to person.
The common cold is a viral infection of the upper respiratory tract. Many different viruses can cause a cold. In busy Melbourne environments such as childcare, schools, public transport, offices and events, these viruses spread easily through droplets and contaminated surfaces.
Colds are usually mild and self limiting in healthy people, but they can still cause several days of discomfort. The immune system responds to the virus by inflaming the lining of the nose and throat, which creates the familiar symptoms of a blocked or runny nose, sore throat and cough.
Cold symptoms usually progress over a day or two. A person may experience a scratchy throat first, then develop a blocked or runny nose, followed by a cough. Nasal mucus often starts clear and watery, then becomes thicker and more opaque as the infection progresses. This change does not automatically mean a bacterial infection.
It is common to feel generally unwell with a cold. Low grade fever, headache, body aches and tiredness are typical, particularly in the first few days. Children may be clingy or off their food, and adults may struggle to keep up with usual work or home tasks until the worst of the infection settles.
Viral infections frequently cause a sore throat. Swallowing can be painful, and the tonsils may appear red and swollen. Small white patches can appear on the tonsils and can be part of viral or bacterial infections. A cough often follows as mucus from the nose and sinuses drips down into the throat.
Even after the nose has cleared, a dry or productive cough can persist for weeks while the airways settle. This can be frustrating but is usually part of normal healing. Persistent or severe throat pain, particularly with high fever and difficulty swallowing, may suggest tonsillitis and should be reviewed by a doctor.
Children in childcare or early school often pick up one viral infection after another, especially through Melbourne’s busier months. Adults who commute, work in public facing roles or live with young children can feel that they are constantly “catching something”.
Most of these infections are mild. However, if someone experiences frequent episodes of severe tonsillitis, repeated ear or sinus infections, or infections that lead to significant time off school or work, further assessment can be useful. A GP may refer to an ENT surgeon such as Dr Stephen Kleid or Dr Simon Braham at Melbourne ENT to consider whether enlarged tonsils, adenoids or nasal issues are contributing.
Allergy symptoms often appear quickly after exposure. A person might be comfortable indoors, then begin sneezing within minutes of stepping into a park on a windy afternoon. Symptoms tend to correlate with specific situations, such as mowing the lawn or visiting a house with pets.
Cold symptoms usually develop more gradually, one to three days after contact with someone who is unwell. A scratchy throat appears first, followed by nasal congestion and then a cough. The pattern is less tied to pollen counts or time outdoors and more to contact with sick people.
With allergies, the nose is frequently itchy, runny and sometimes blocked. The discharge is usually clear and watery. Long bouts of sneezing are common, particularly in the morning or soon after a trigger is encountered.
In a cold, the nose feels heavy and blocked, with mucus that becomes thicker over time. Itching is less prominent. People often describe feeling stuffed up, and their sense of smell may be reduced until the infection resolves.
Allergy related eye symptoms include itching, redness, swelling and watering. The eyes can be very uncomfortable, and people may rub them frequently. Contact lenses may be difficult to tolerate on high pollen days in Melbourne.
With a cold, the eyes may feel tired or slightly irritated, but intense itching is less typical. Eye symptoms may be mild or absent, and the main focus of discomfort is usually the nose, throat and general achiness.
In allergic rhinitis, the throat usually feels tickly rather than sharply painful. Post nasal drip encourages frequent throat clearing and a dry, irritating cough. Symptoms may flare when lying flat or at night.
In a cold, the throat is often genuinely sore, particularly when swallowing. The cough may start dry and then become more productive as mucus clears from the respiratory tract. Talking for long periods can be uncomfortable while the infection is active.
Allergies rarely cause a true fever. People often feel worn out because they do not sleep well and are constantly battling symptoms, but they do not usually feel acutely ill.
Colds, on the other hand, often bring low grade fever, body aches and a heavy, sick feeling. Even mild viral infections can temporarily reduce appetite, mood and energy levels until the immune system clears the virus.
Allergic rhinitis often persists throughout the pollen season or whenever indoor triggers are present. Symptoms may vary in intensity but rarely disappear completely during peak times. Many people recognise a yearly pattern, with problems returning at the same time each spring or summer.
A typical cold settles within about a week. The cough may outlast other symptoms, but the blocked nose and sore throat improve. If nose and throat symptoms are present on most days for weeks and are clearly linked to high pollen days or specific environments, allergies are more likely than a continuous run of new viruses.
Colds are contagious and tend to spread through households, classrooms and workplaces. If one person becomes unwell, others often develop similar symptoms within days.
Allergies are not infectious. Several family members may seem “sick” at once because they share genes and live in the same pollen or dust filled environment, but they are not giving a disease to each other. Recognising this can help reduce unnecessary concern and avoid repeated courses of antibiotics when they are unlikely to help.
Antibiotics target bacteria, not viruses and not allergic inflammation. They are essential for serious bacterial infections such as some cases of tonsillitis, sinusitis or pneumonia, but they do not treat a simple cold or hay fever. Taking antibiotics for a viral infection will not shorten the illness or relieve itching and sneezing.
Understanding that most summer colds and allergy flares are not bacterial helps patients and doctors reserve antibiotics for situations where they are truly needed. This makes treatment safer and more effective in the long term.
Antibiotics can cause side effects, including stomach upset, diarrhoea, rashes and thrush. Occasionally, more serious reactions occur. Using antibiotics when they are unlikely to help exposes people to these risks with little or no benefit.
Overuse of antibiotics also contributes to antibiotic resistance in the community. Bacteria that survive exposure to antibiotics can become harder to treat in the future. Protecting the usefulness of antibiotics is an important shared responsibility.
Thick or discoloured mucus is often assumed to mean a bacterial infection, but this is a normal part of the immune response in many viral illnesses. Long standing nasal congestion and facial pressure related to allergies can be mistaken for repeated sinus infections. When symptoms are not correctly identified, people may be given repeated antibiotic prescriptions that bring only brief or no improvement.
Addressing the underlying problem, such as allergic rhinitis, structural nasal blockage or enlarged tonsils, is more effective than repeatedly treating presumed infections that are not truly there.
At Melbourne ENT, Dr Stephen Kleid and Dr Simon Braham focus on accurate diagnosis. They listen carefully to the history, examine the nose, throat and ears, and may use nasal endoscopy when needed. Their aim is to identify whether allergies, repeated viral infections, structural issues or a combination of these are contributing to symptoms.
Rather than relying on repeated antibiotics, they help patients and their GPs plan targeted treatment. This may include optimising allergy control, monitoring symptoms or discussing surgical options when structural problems or recurrent tonsillitis are clearly impacting health and quality of life.
Mild sore throats with colds are common. Tonsillitis is usually more severe, with marked throat pain, fever, difficulty swallowing and a generally unwell feeling. When tonsillitis occurs frequently, it can seriously affect school attendance, work productivity and family life.
In these cases, an ENT assessment can help decide whether ongoing medical management or tonsillectomy is the better long term option. Melbourne ENT considers how often infections occur, how severe they are and how much they disrupt daily life before recommending surgery.
Enlarged tonsils and adenoids can narrow the airway, particularly during sleep. Children may snore loudly, breathe through the mouth and toss and turn at night. Adults may experience snoring or obstructive sleep apnoea with daytime tiredness and poor concentration.
Allergies and colds can worsen these problems by adding extra swelling in the nose and throat. At Melbourne ENT, the airway is assessed as a whole. If enlarged tonsils or adenoids are contributing to sleep disordered breathing, surgery may be discussed as part of a broader treatment plan.
Chronic post nasal drip can cause ongoing throat irritation, coughing and voice strain. This is particularly difficult for people who speak for a living or who sing. Allergies, chronic sinusitis and structural problems in the nose can all play a role.
Treating the underlying cause can reduce the need for constant throat clearing and allow the voice to recover. In some cases, speech pathology input is also helpful to improve voice technique and reduce strain.
Some throat symptoms suggest a more serious problem and need urgent medical assessment. These include severe one sided throat pain, difficulty swallowing saliva, drooling, a muffled voice or any sign of breathing difficulty. High fever with significant neck swelling can also be a warning sign.
In Victoria, urgent care may be needed through emergency departments at hospitals such as Royal Melbourne Hospital or the Royal Victorian Eye and Ear Hospital. If these red flag symptoms appear, it is important not to delay seeking help.
At an initial appointment in St Kilda East, Melbourne ENT takes time to understand the full story. Patients are asked about when symptoms started, how they vary with the seasons, how often infections occur and which treatments have already been tried. The impact on sleep, school, work and family life is also explored.
For children, parents are encouraged to share observations about snoring, breathing at night, behaviour, concentration and growth. This information helps build a clear picture of how nose and throat problems are affecting the child’s wellbeing.
The surgeon examines the ears, nose, throat and neck. Inside the nose, they look for signs of allergic inflammation, deviation of the septum, enlarged turbinates or polyps. The mouth and throat are checked for the size and appearance of the tonsils and the general condition of the throat lining. The neck is examined for any lumps or tenderness.
In many cases, a slender telescope is gently passed through the nose after local anaesthetic spray. This nasal endoscopy allows a detailed view of the nasal passages, sinus openings and the area where the adenoids sit. The findings can often be explained to patients in real time, helping them to understand what is happening inside their nose and throat.
After gathering history and examination findings, the surgeon considers how much of the problem is allergic, how much is due to repeated infections and whether structural issues are present. For example, a patient with a strong seasonal pattern, itchy eyes and a normal nasal structure may benefit mainly from allergy treatment. Another patient may have very enlarged tonsils and clear sleep disordered breathing, pointing toward a surgical solution.
Both Dr Stephen Kleid and Dr Simon Braham bring many years of ENT experience to this decision making process. They discuss the options, explain likely outcomes and support patients in choosing a plan that fits their goals and lifestyle.
Melbourne ENT works alongside GPs, paediatricians, sleep physicians, allergy specialists and speech pathologists where needed. GPs remain central in ongoing care, particularly for managing asthma, mild allergies and general health. Clear communication between team members helps ensure that treatment is coordinated and that patients receive consistent advice.
For allergic rhinitis, regular use of intranasal corticosteroid sprays is often the most effective long term treatment. These sprays reduce inflammation in the nasal lining and can significantly ease congestion, sneezing and post nasal drip when used correctly. Non sedating antihistamines are useful for controlling itching and sneezing, especially when exposure to triggers is high.
Saline sprays or rinses can help flush allergens and mucus from the nose. In more complex cases, allergy testing and consideration of allergen immunotherapy may be appropriate, typically arranged in conjunction with an allergy specialist.
Most viral colds need time, rest, fluids and simple pain relief. Throat lozenges, warm drinks and steam inhalation can provide comfort. Decongestant sprays may be used for short periods under medical guidance.
When infection is clearly bacterial, such as in some cases of tonsillitis or sinusitis, antibiotics may be prescribed. The decision is based on the pattern and severity of symptoms, examination findings and underlying health. The aim is to treat significant bacterial infections without overusing antibiotics for conditions that are likely to resolve on their own.
Surgery is considered when structural or recurrent problems continue despite good medical care. Tonsillectomy and adenoidectomy may be recommended for patients with frequent, severe tonsillitis or significant sleep disordered breathing linked to enlarged tonsils or adenoids. The decision takes into account the frequency and severity of symptoms and their impact on daily functioning.
Nasal surgery such as septoplasty and turbinoplasty can improve airflow when a crooked septum or enlarged turbinates cause persistent obstruction. For some patients with chronic sinusitis that has not responded to medication, sinus surgery can open blocked drainage pathways and reduce future infections.
When surgery is a possibility, Melbourne ENT ensures that patients receive clear explanations about what is involved. Dr Stephen Kleid and Dr Simon Braham discuss the nature of the operation, the expected benefits, potential risks and the typical recovery process. They draw on their experience at major Victorian hospitals, including the Royal Victorian Eye and Ear Hospital and Royal Melbourne Hospital, to guide safe practice and decision making.
Patients are encouraged to ask questions and to involve family members or carers in discussions. The goal is for each person to feel informed and supported at every step.
In Australia, many ENT procedures such as tonsillectomy, adenoidectomy, septoplasty and sinus surgery attract a Medicare rebate when performed for medically necessary reasons. With a valid referral from a GP or another specialist, Medicare pays part of the surgeon’s fee and hospital costs. Private health insurance, where held, may contribute further, depending on the policy and level of cover.
There is often a gap between the total fee and the Medicare rebate. At Melbourne ENT, patients are given written estimates of fees before surgery, including item numbers that can be checked with Medicare and any private health fund. Staff explain likely out of pocket costs and encourage patients to clarify details with their insurer so that there are no financial surprises around the time of surgery.
People who know they are prone to hay fever can combine medical treatment with practical strategies. Checking daily pollen counts, keeping windows closed on high pollen days, using recirculated air in the car and wearing sunglasses outdoors can all help. Showering and changing clothes after time outside can reduce pollen carried indoors and may ease evening symptoms.
Good hand hygiene, avoiding close contact with sick people where possible and staying home when unwell remain important measures against colds. For throat health, staying hydrated, limiting alcohol and avoiding smoking support the natural defences of the upper airway. People with reflux should work with their GP to manage it, as uncontrolled reflux can worsen throat symptoms.
Protecting the throat over the long term involves controlling allergies, treating significant infections appropriately and paying attention to early warning signs. Recurrent severe tonsillitis, persistent hoarseness, difficulty swallowing, loud snoring or pauses in breathing during sleep should prompt medical review. Where symptoms persist despite good medical care, a referral to Melbourne ENT for specialist assessment can clarify whether further treatment, including surgery, may be helpful.
Yes, it is possible to develop allergies for the first time as an adult, even if childhood passed without hay fever. Over time, your immune system can become sensitised to Melbourne and Victorian allergens such as grass pollen, dust mites or pet dander. Once this threshold is reached, you may suddenly begin to notice itchy eyes, sneezing, a runny nose or a tickly throat each spring or summer.
Because adult onset symptoms can resemble a lingering cold or sinus infection, they are sometimes mislabelled for years. If your so called colds keep recurring at the same time each year, or are clearly worse on high pollen days or after being outdoors, it is sensible to discuss the possibility of allergic rhinitis with your GP or an ENT specialist at Melbourne ENT.
If your symptoms reliably flare after mowing, gardening, walking in the park or watching sport outdoors, allergies are more likely than a series of new colds. Cutting grass stirs up large amounts of pollen and plant particles, particularly in suburban Melbourne. For someone with grass pollen sensitivity, this can trigger sudden sneezing, nasal congestion, eye irritation and a tickly throat that feel very similar to a cold.
True colds usually appear a day or two after close contact with someone who is already unwell, and they follow a more gradual pattern. If your nose and throat feel much better on rainy days, in winter or when you have been indoors with windows closed, that is another clue that pollen related allergy may be the main driver. An ENT review can help confirm this and guide a treatment plan that lets you keep enjoying outdoor activities with fewer symptoms.
Yes, nasal congestion from allergies can contribute to snoring and sleep disordered breathing. When the nose is blocked, you are more likely to breathe through your mouth. Mouth breathing changes the shape and stability of the airway at the back of the throat during sleep, which can increase vibration and collapse, especially in people who already have a narrow airway.
If you or your partner notice that snoring is much louder or more frequent during Melbourne’s pollen season, or when hay fever is active, improved allergy control may make a noticeable difference. At Melbourne ENT, Dr Stephen Kleid and Dr Simon Braham can assess how much of your snoring or suspected sleep apnoea is related to nasal congestion and how much is due to tonsils, adenoids or other structural factors, then suggest appropriate treatment options.
Children commonly have frequent infections, but certain patterns suggest that tonsils or adenoids may need closer attention. These include multiple episodes of high fever and severe throat pain each year, significant time off school, difficulty swallowing, very large tonsils visible in the mouth, loud snoring, pauses in breathing at night or daytime tiredness and behavioural changes.
If your child seems constantly unwell through summer, breathes mainly through their mouth or has disturbed sleep, it is reasonable to talk with your GP about an ENT referral. At Melbourne ENT, children are assessed gently. The surgeon examines the size and health of the tonsils and adenoids, listens carefully to the history and then discusses whether watchful waiting, medical treatment or surgery is the most appropriate path.
A persistent sore or scratchy throat during summer, especially with negative swabs for bacterial infection, can indeed be related to the nose and sinuses. Allergic rhinitis can cause continuous post nasal drip, where mucus trickles down the back of the throat and irritates the lining. Dry indoor air, air conditioning, talking loudly and frequent throat clearing can all add to the irritation.
Other factors such as reflux from the stomach or voice strain can overlap with allergy. An ENT assessment can help tease out these different contributors. By examining the nose, throat and voice box, and reviewing the pattern of symptoms, Melbourne ENT can advise whether allergy treatment, voice care, reflux management or structural surgery is likely to offer the best relief.
Yes, indoor environments can amplify nose and throat problems that begin with allergies or viruses. Air conditioning can dry the nose and throat, making mucus thicker and harder to clear. Recirculated air in offices or shops may concentrate dust, fumes or other irritants. In some Melbourne workplaces, exposure to chemicals or fine particles can further irritate the airways.
If your symptoms are noticeably worse at work or in certain buildings and improve when you are away, it suggests that environment plays a role. Simple steps such as using saline nasal sprays, staying well hydrated and improving ventilation can help. If problems persist, particularly with chronic cough or voice change, an ENT review can check for any structural or inflammatory changes and guide further action.
It is very common for nose and throat symptoms to fluctuate. Many people find that on the day they finally see a specialist, their hay fever has settled or their latest cold is improving. Even so, the appointment is still valuable. The detailed history you provide about the timing, triggers, frequency and impact of your symptoms is often just as important as what is seen on examination.
Even if your nose and throat appear relatively calm on the day, an ENT specialist at Melbourne ENT can assess structural features such as the septum, turbinates, tonsils and adenoids, and look for signs of long term inflammation or scarring. They can also review previous test results from your GP. Together, this information builds a clearer picture of why your summer symptoms keep returning and what can be done to reduce their impact over the long term.
For most people, a first episode of summer sniffles, mild hay fever or a simple cold is best assessed by a GP. Your GP can help distinguish between allergies and infection, recommend appropriate medication and advise on self care. They can also identify when investigations or specialist input are warranted.
ENT specialist review is particularly useful when symptoms are persistent, recurrent or significantly affecting sleep, school, work or quality of life. Frequent tonsillitis, chronic nasal obstruction, suspected sleep apnoea, long standing post nasal drip or voice changes are all common reasons for referral. Children who seem “always sick” through Melbourne’s warmer months or adults who never feel fully recovered between illnesses may benefit from a detailed ENT assessment.
Melbourne ENT aims to provide clear, compassionate and evidence based care. Most patients with summer allergies or colds will not need surgery, but for those who do, careful planning and follow up are offered. With the combined expertise of Dr Stephen Kleid and Dr Simon Braham, patients receive individualised care that focuses on improving breathing, sleep and overall wellbeing.
If ongoing summer allergies, repeated colds or persistent throat problems are affecting you or your child, consider arranging a review with your GP to discuss whether a referral to Melbourne ENT would be helpful. For more information about the clinic in St Kilda East, the services offered and the care provided by Dr Stephen Kleid and Dr Simon Braham, please contact the practice directly.
Summer in Melbourne brings long evenings, beach days, sport and time outdoors. It also brings…
Every summer, many people from Melbourne and across Victoria board flights for holidays, family visits…
For many people in Melbourne and across Victoria, blocked noses, hay fever, and sinus problems…